At 10:35am on November 21st, 1950 2 trains collided head on a few miles South of Cedarside British Columbia. 21 people were killed, 4 crewmen and 17 soldiers bound for the Korean War. A young telegraph operator, Alfred John “Jack” Atherton, was blame for the crash and charged with manslaughter. His trial would be one of the most dramatic in Canadian history.
A Father’s Plea
His father had anticipated that charges would be brought against his son over the crash. Atherton’s parents lived in Zealandia, Saskatchewan, and their Member of Parliament for the riding was a man by the name of John Diefenbaker. In December 1950, Atherton’s father contacted Diefenbaker and asked that he serve as defence counsel for his son. Diefenbaker, who at that point was 10 years into his 39-year Parliamentary career, declined saying that Parliament came first, and his wife Edna was very sick with leukemia. Another issue was that he was not a lawyer in British Columbia and would have to pass the bar there.
It would have likely ended there for Diefenbaker, but Atherton’s father was a very driven man. He knew that Edna Diefenbaker was a powerful influence on her husband, and he would sneak into her Saskatoon hospital room to speak with her. At the time, Diefenbaker was in Australia attending a Commonwealth Parliamentary meeting.
Later, Diefenbaker came to see his wife and she told him that Jack Atherton had come to see her about her son’s case. She would say quote:
“Everyone in the CNR is running away from responsibility for what appears to have been a grievous disregard for human lives.”
Diefenbaker told her that the British Columbia Bar was notoriously difficult to pass, and the fee was $1,500. Edna then told her husband she already told the Atherton’s that he would take the case. With that, Diefenbaker took the case.